Chairman’s 2012 AGM Address

cropped-logo_small.jpgChairman’s 2012 AGM Address

50 years of the Society

Last year I reviewed the activities of the Society’s Committee under my chairmanship over the past 10 years or so. I have now been reminded by the Secretary, Dr Ivor Johnson, that this is the 50th anniversary of the founding of the Society. I believe it was formally instituted on 16 April 1962. One of its founder members was Bill Hope Jones who was our president until his death a few years ago. He continued to actively support the Society until he died.

Missing Records—can you help?

I have looked up some of the records of the Society which cover the decade of the 90s. If anyone else knows where the previous records are going back into the60s 70s and 80s then please do let us know. I don’t say they had an easy time of it in the 90s. There was the major planning appeal in relation to Buckland rings in 1987 and the ongoing issue of the siting of the hospital all the way through the 90s.

My reason for joining

It was the possibility of being able to push forward the development of the Hospital that encouraged me to join the Society’s Committee and to become its Chairman and very soon after, probably not due to any great effort on my part, the hospital was built and is a very splendid facility for the Town, whether one likes its location or not.

All change with the new millennium

Apart from the Hospital, things in the minutes in the 90s were some what routine. I don’t know whether it was the fault of the new Committee but, as I set out in my last Chairman’s speech last year, everything then happened. The Chicken Factory Site issue became active and has had a mind of its own ever since. Mr Prescott decided to encourage development on Brownfield sites and incorporated back gardens into the term Brownfield. That started a battle which lasted several years until the planners came round to our way of thinking following a public meeting, and the Government eventually modified its directives. previous meetings with envy. Possibly two or three letters to be discussed. These days not a day goes by without emails circulating amongst the Committee dealing with all these issues. We take the details them as read and discuss the wider principles at our Committee meetings. It is principles upon which an Amenity Society needs to operate. Its mission and message need to be clear. It is not an organisation for individual one-off issues important as they are. It has to look at the overall picture and argue to its strengths. That involves getting a good relationship with the planners and the local councillors, which I hope we have now achieved. That does not mean that we all agree all the time. As has happened this year we had surprise decisions not only from the District Councillors over Wetherspoon’s but also from the Town Councillors over Redrow. That does not mean that we fallout but that we put over our point of view to ensure that at the end of the daythe issue has been fully debated and properly considered by those bodies, do not agree with the current plan, but understandable. It is also understandable that a single issue organisation such as “Lymington Last Shores” using a website to attract support, fights on to get a much lower density. The Committee however feel that it has adopted a reasonable and responsible approach which prevents the Town from the risk of the 300 unit development rising to 4 to 5 stories.

…and Wightlink…

On the issue of the ferries the Society has finally seen to a conclusion, in the recent public enquiry, its efforts toensure that the introduction of the ferries was carried out on the basis of all appropriate investigations being carried out by the authorities rather than the presentation of a fait-accompli by Wightlink.

…and Wetherspoons

On Wetherspoon’s we have been surprised and shocked at the Council’s decision to grant the application in the teeth of local opposition and have expended some of our funds in establishing whether there were grounds to challenge that decision. There were, but on a pragmatic basis when it was clear to us that the decision would be likely to be repeated if set-aside after a very risky and expensive judicial review, the right decision was not to go further. Jonathan Hutchinson would like me to say that if any members criticise that decision he would like to know whether they were one of the few members who responded to his request for their views in making that decision.

This is your opportunity to say whether the Committee is doing what you think is right. The Advertiser and Times suggested that we were raising a white flag over Wetherspoon’s. I have sought to justify our position in the local paper. If you have any views let us have them tonight.

The Committee have to act on your behalf. I sit on various committees and Ihave to say that this is one of the most active and well integrated committees that I am involved with and I am lucky to be Chairman of it. I hope you will continue to support it.

Whetherspoons letter to the editor

Editor Lymington times

Sir

I appreciate that it is necessary for front page reporting to summarise an issue and get a headline but when this headline does not really reflect the true position I hope you will allow a right of reply on your letters page.

The Lymington Society is not in the business of waving white flags. The Society is a body which looks after the interests of the whole Town on an objective and practical basis bearing in mind that any particular issue, whilst important, is one of many and once that issue has been dealt with as fully as possible it is time to move on and look after other issues. This is the distinction between the Lymington Society as an amenity Society, which has now coming up its 50th anniversary, and other single issue groups who may well be prepared to fight on until the last gasp over the issue with which they are concerned.

In the case of Wetherspoon’s we opposed both applications. We encouraged responses and there was a huge response of 900 individuals against planning permission on the second application. The decision did not reflect the views of the Town or the 900 objectors and the Society spent a lot of its resources in time and money in establishing whether the decision could be challenged. It might have been possible to challenge it but the view taken by the Committee was that even if there was a successful challenge then it was extremely likely that the same councillors would vote in the same way on another decision, which would be required as a result of a successful legal challenge, and a lot of time and effort would have been spent for nothing.

The Lymington Society has never been involved in licensing issues because they particularly affect individuals who live nearby. However if the licensing could have been a back door to preventing a public house in such a sensitive location then we would have objected, but consider seriously whether the council, which is now the licensing authority, would be likely to refuse an alcohol licence for a public house for which it had just granted planning permission.

All that could be achieved would be to limit the licensing hours, but that is a matter which is best argued by the neighbours for their own particular needs and by the police in respect of public order.

The main body of the press release was as follows and I hope you will allow it to be printed here. “The Lymington Society have supported the 900 individual objections to the location of the proposed Wetherspoons public house next to the church. A considerable amount of time and effort was spent in doing so and considering the validity of the eventual permission passed.

The permission has been granted and there is a hearing in respect of licensing. The Society’s opposition is not so much as to the extent of the licensing but to the fact of the public house in that location itself.

The Society’s view is that the hours of licensing and any conditions placed on the premises are matter for the neighbours who would be directly affected, the police who will need to monitor it and potentially the Town Council if they feel it appropriate to express a view on licensing in the Town centre.

It has not been the Society’s practice to become involved in licensing matters which would have the effect of preferring or disadvantaging one licensed premises over another once planning permission has been approved in principle.

If as a result of the operation of the premises, representations to the licensing authority are clearly in the interests of the Town then Society would reconsider its position.”

The Society’s Committee is conscious that the combination of it’s lack of legal action against the Council in respect of Wetherspoon’s and its acceptance of the current plans in relation to the Redrow site, are tending to give the misleading impression that the Committee is accepting the power of large organisations in pushing through planning applications which the townspeople don’t want.

The Committee can only deal with the art of the possible and if it is likely, as in the case of Wetherspoon’s, that the Council Planning Committee will maintain a subsequent decision, and in the case of Redrow that the developers could fall back on a previous planning application with a extra 100 units then the Committee will object as long as reasonably possible, or negotiate the best outcome, and continue to deal with other issues. Currently the next issue is the amount of green belt land surrounding Lymington that should be allocated for housing.

The Society’s AGM has been advertised for 20 March at 7:30 PM at the Community Centre and of course members are welcome to take the Committee to task if it is not carrying out their wishes. The meeting has been publicly advertised and it is hoped that non members will attend as observers and if they feel strongly about the Town, then join the Society and make their voices heard. The first question asked by any inspector or barrister in any planning appeal or enquiry is to know what membership the Lymington Society represents!

Yours sincerely

Clive Sutton

Chairman

Lymington Society Urges NFDC Rethink on Wetherspoons Decision

Lymington Society Urges NFDC Rethink on Wetherspoons Decision Following Legal Advice

The Society very much welcomes investment and jobs coming to the Town at this difficult time.  However following the approval of the revised planning application by Wetherspoons for change of use of 47 and 48 St Thomas’ Street to a public house in the building immediately adjacent to the parish church, the Lymington Society has received many expressions of concern both from its members and non-members alike.

Concern has been raised that the meeting at which the decision was taken did not fully consider the valid planning reasons for which the Council had earlier refused a near-identical application. Nor did it fully consider the Environmental Health Officer’s report concluding that the proposed change of use would result in a substantial loss of amenity for nearby residents, or take account of the unanimous opposition of the Town’s elected Councillors, or of the unprecedented number of objections registered during the consultation stage.

These concerns have now led to the Society taking advice as to the legality of the decision which has been made.

That advice is that the majority decision made by the Development Control Committee, is legally flawed because the decision did not take account of the earlier unanimous decision to refuse the application.

The Society has now written to the NFDC urging them to set aside the previous decision and to re-assess the application afresh taking full regard for the valid planning reasons set out both in the previous decision and in the Planning Officer’s recommendation for refusal.

The Society and those who oppose the application, believe that a further meeting would give Councillors a fresh opportunity to take into account the strong views of the Town against the proposal. In addition it would give them the chance to take further note of the unanimous refusal of the earlier application and recommendation of the Planning Officers for refusal together with the additional report of the Environmental Health Officer who also recommended refusal.

The Society hopes that those Councillors from outside the town who voted in favour of it, against the opinion of Lymington’s elected representatives from both the Town and the District Council, will reconsider their position or at least abstain, to allow Lymington to have a fair chance of making its own decision as to the introduction of a large “destination” public house in a location which so many people feel is the wrong place.

Speaking on behalf of the society, its chairman Clive Sutton said:

The Lymington Society is concerned that the decision of the Development Control Committee to approve the planning application by Wetherspoons for change of use of 47 and 48 St Thomas’ Street was taken on the basis of sentiment regarding the company concerned, rather than on the extremely important local planning issues at stake and against the recommendation of the Town’s elected representatives. 

In addition the Committee failed to properly take account of its previous unanimous refusal for a virtually identical application, or to give sufficient regard to the Environmental Health Officer’s recommendation for refusal due to the “substantial loss of amenity” likely to be suffered  by nearby residents.

The Lymington Society, which is often described as a watchdog on environmental and planning issues, feels that it has a duty to ensure that the decision on the change of use application is fairly arrived at by the Development Control Committee and that the concerns of the Lymington Councillors who had taken the trouble to vote against this proposal on a democratic basis, together with the over 900 people who had written letters of objection, have been properly taken into account. 

The Society’s clear advice is that the decision by the Development Control Committee is legally flawed as it failed to properly consider their previous unanimous refusal for a nearly identical application and that a legal challenge to the decision could be successfully mounted.  This advice confirms the feelings of many who attended the meeting that it was not conducted fairly.

We are therefore urging the NFDC to set aside this legally flawed decision and to allow the Development Control Committee to debate this proposal again.

A new meeting should this time take full account of all the important policy issues which led to the previous unanimous refusal, together with the concerns raised in the Environmental Health Officer’s report arising from the severe impact of the change of use on nearby residents in St Thomas’s Park.